Best Response So Far to End of Year Gifts

After taking a year off, I’ve done it again: I gave $25 year-end gifts to 20 national nonprofits that I had not previously supported so that I can see what kind of donor communications I get throughout the course of year. I’ve called this the “What I Got When I Gave” experiment, but you might remember it as the “Only a third of nonprofits followed up or said thank you after the email receipt” experiment from previous years.

This time, I gave 10 of the gifts by cashing in credit card miles with Capital One. They cover the processing fees, so nonprofits get the full $25, which is nice. Those gifts are processed by Network for Good, which means that it will likely be a month before the charities know about the gift. I’m willing to cut them some slack until February because of that.

But the other ten were given directly through the nonprofit’s website. Thus my expectations for this second group are a bit higher, since that’s where they explicitly ask that we donate.

The award for best response so far goes to the Wilderness Society. On January 5, I received this email:

Wilderness Society End of Year Thank You Email

Here’s what I like about it:

  • Specifically references a year-end gift to remind me that, yeah, I did give them some money last week.
  • Gives me credit for making good work possible (“Thanks to you, we’ll have critical resources to protect the wild. . . Your donation and your voice will make a difference.”)
  • Commits to sharing results (“We will be reporting on our progress in the coming months.”)
  • Gives me other things to do, if I want (connect on Facebook, take action, read the blog, etc.)
  • Treats me as one of the team (” . . . your continuing participation as a member of The Wilderness Society community.)

Bravo, Wilderness Society! This is actually one of three emails I have received from them. On January 4, it was a campfire recipe, on the 5th, it was this email, and on the 6th, it was about the “my wilderness” contest. We’ll see what comes next.

I’ll report more results from other nonprofits as they come in (or don’t). I’ll also share some interesting notes from the end-of-year donation process itself, including some good landing pages and thank you pages. And yes, I’ll name names again this year if I don’t hear anything at all (but not until mid-February).



© 2007-2017, Nonprofit Marketing Guide. All Rights Reserved.

Share This Post On
  • Love this experiment, Kivi! Thank you!

  • Pingback: A Year of Donations « Jessica Green()

  • Vickey

    Kivi, we use NFG for our online giving portal, and get an email from them every time someone donates. So  waiting until mid-February to evaluate responses is pretty generous. There’s no reason why a non-profit should experience delays in knowing who gave what when.

  • Pingback: A Year of Donations |()

  • Pingback: Nonprofit Thank You Letters - Resources for You | Nonprofit Marketing Guide()

  • Los comentarios ponen de relieve las apuestas ms amplias del franco gobernador durante un evento que podra ser una afinacin para una eventual campaa presidencial. Si decide competir, Christie comenzara a realizar campaa a mediados de su segundo perodo como gobernador.

  • Li Jinyu points out, he is not recommended for big adjustment to the team, but the team still needs proper reinforcements, "last year I was halfway over, after six months of running, WeiBilliards beauty referee Zhu Ying in the "five rich generation" husband pedigree yesterday, billiards beauty referee the Ying and her boyfriend in the Civil Affairs Bureau license photo spread on the internet

  • Cada vez menos empresas agrcolas y de ms tamao dominan la produccin de alimentos en todo Estados Unidos.

  • Bronson Arroyo (9 9) igual su mayor cifra de la campaa al recibir siete carreras, en slo tres entradas y dos tercios, su permanencia en el montculo ms corta en la temporada.



  • Prom dresses can have an endless number of looks. On shoulder prom dresses are just one of the many styles of evening dresses that are available. A teenage girl can wear a dress that has a vintage style or she can opt for a look that has edginess to its style.

  • Wonder, de 62 aos, espera que el rapero de 30 aos ganador del premio Grammy entienda la perspectiva de la familia Till y elija sus palabras con ms cuidado en el futuro.

  • More News HeadlinesBusiness: Shipping containers can open export market to farmersWe Create Here: Why I choose to create hereGovernment: Three little words make big difference in Iowa legislative ethics rulesPublic Safety: Jury finds Johnathan Mitchell not guilty in 2011 cab driver homicideEducation: New cellular telephone tower proposed for Johnson Elementary SchoolInvestigative: Economic development aid owed to Iowa ‘relatively small, Branstad says

  • NEW YORK Las autoridades de Nueva York dieron los primeros pasos en la apelacin al fallo de una jueza federal que impone reformas a la estrategia que usa la polica municipal despus de determinar que escoge intencionalmente a grupos minoritarios.

  • Lynn (10 1) apenas toler una carrera y tres imparables en seis entradas y consigui dobles dgitos en triunfos en la primera mitad de la campaa en sus dos aos en la rotacin, yndose 11 4 el ao pasado y participando en el Juego de Estrellas. Lynn se sum a su compaero de equipo Adam Wainwright y a Jordan Zimmermann, de Washington, en el liderato de la Nacional.

  • La casa editorial tiene planes de traducir el libro a otros idiomas en el futuro, agreg la portavoz.

  • I know I made my bed so lie in it, so no reason stating the obvious. I had a mistress for 2 years and she called and told my wife when I finally told her I would never leave my wife for her. My wife and I stayed together and trying to work it out. Now the mistress is threatening to give some info that she held back like my mistress and I having sex in our marital bed and our sexual activities which I feel is embarrasing. I think the wife may try to forgive, only because she kind of has low self esteem, but not entirely sure what she will do. My question is what do I do with my X mistress go back to her to keep her quiet?

  • A spokesman for the Yorkshire Bank, which commissioned the study, said: “The trendy new build flat in the city could become a thing of the past. The younger age group that aspire to live in this type of property is increasingly priced out of the market.

  • Bogot El Gobierno colombiano inici hoy la subasta de licencias del espectro radioelctrico para operar la telefona mvil de cuarta generacin (4G), proceso que las autoridades del sector consideran de los ms importantes que se hayan hecho en Amrica Latina.

  • The picks weren’t entirely monochromatic. Hurley suggested a $5,745, pink plaid Chanel skirt suit shot with gold thread. “Very Barbie,” he called it.

  • McLoughlin, 22, arrived with her entourage, dressed in a strappy blue and yellow floral Balenciaga dress.

  • This year, joined Madison and Mulholland’s Ultimate Nominee gift bag given to Oscar nominees and presenters and other prominent actresses including Kate Winslet, Penelope Cruz, Meryl Streep, Amy Adams, Jennifer Aniston, Sarah Jessica Parker, Reese Witherspoon, Cate Blanchett, Eva Mendes and Scarlett Johansson. The eco friendly online store also participated in the pre Oscars HAVEN house 3 day swag/entertainment event held in Beverly Hills where preview products from its Fall 2009 collection were displayed and given away to Hollywood insiders such as Paula Abdul, Barry Bostwick, James Denton, Dustin Lance Black, among others.

  • Lida Baday, Jeremy Laing and Dsquared2 were among the other Canadian labels showcased.

  • Tory Burch’s thought is actually proper, within the using elegance, get in touch with with regard to customers to actually really feel cozy inside their pores and skin. That’s very typical, people don’t know techniques to obtain a cozy match, as well as nevertheless it won’t travel the actual manufacturer. Clothing, you’re keen on enables 1 to match your favored feet ahead, the actual business understand this. A brand new seems reaches danger for people which don’t have self confidence within the people a person assistance. Whenever you wish to fill up numerous your own change, it is advisable to investigation with regard to assist through people who regard a person. Their own recommendations as well as suggestions also may help a person make use of your coating, you don’t actually understand.

  • La ltima entrega de la saga Bond, uno de los estrenos ms esperados del ao, supone tambin el retorno del emblemtico “Q”, interpretado por un joven Ben Wishaw que asumi la responsabilidad de sustituir al emblemtico Desmond Llewelyn, fallecido en 1999.

  • Hellickson admiti cinco carreras y cinco imparables, regal tres bases por bolas, golpe a un bateador y ponch a uno, y los Rays cayeron a un juego y medio detrs de Boston en la divisin Este de la Americana.

  • I sought to bring many problems to the attention of the Rhee administration,especially because she requested that we do just that when she accepted her position with the elaborate announcement on the steps of the Wilson Building, but I was victimized and branded a trouble maker for doing so. Except for apparently halting the viewing of television on the job by the special education coordinator, very few of my other concerns which were actually more egregious violations of the law were addressed by the Rhee administration and the special education supervisors that work downtown. I actually witnessed a dilution of the supervisor’s power under Rhee. Though supervisors, technically, are to oversee the school’s special education operations so that violations cited in this article do not occur, under Rhee, they were not allowed to criticize the principals or contradict the principals. In an instance where the principals were ignorant of special education law (as one of my principals actually admitted in an open meeting) or dismissive of it, violations were bound to occur.